Thursday, 27 February 2014

Atheists Shouldn't Call Religion A Mental Illness: Chris Stedman

"Well, you're cray cray!" (source)

Chris Stedman has published a thought-provoking and no doubt controversial post in the Religious News Service.

5 reasons atheists shouldn’t call religion a mental illness
It seems clear to me that religion isn’t a form of mental illness, and that calling it one reflects a shallow understanding of both mental illness and religion—or, worse still, a knowing attempt to use mental illness as an insult.
Go read it, a couple of times. Like me, you could very well get annoyed at it. Now read it again.

I cannot say I agree with all of it, but I am still thinking it over. It's quite thought-provoking.

Anyway, my first reaction -- like most atheists, I think -- was to angrily dismiss all this as some kind of underhanded attempt to shield religion. When I see people behaving in a completely crazy irrational way, my brain often reaches for the C-word. That's just what it is. It's cray, okay?

I also felt like a very solid rhetorical tool was being threatened; that perhaps we were being asked to banish the obvious in some act of political correctness. 

The article referred to a Facebook post by American Atheists president David Silverman, whom I greatly admire. He is talking about a recent horrible act of religiously-motivated criminal negligence by Christian faith-healer parents that left their second child dead.
We must recognize religion as brainwashing. We must recognize the (hyper) religious as mentally damaged. We must take responsibility as a society, because we permit this to happen as a society. 
I completely agree with David and, if I hadn't read Stedman's article, the assignment of mentally damaged to the parents as being somehow inaccurate or even harmful to others with legitimate mental illness would have never even crossed my mind.

I thought about it though. Do mentally ill people out there deserve to be lumped in with people who are so deluded that they believe a magical man in the sky will come down and save their children from illness? Don't they have a hard enough time already without extra stigma?

Now take this excellent point by Sam Harris:
If you think that saying a few Latin words over your pancakes is going to turn them into the body of Elvis Presley, you have lost you mind, but you think more or less the same thing about a cracker and the body of Jesus, you are just a Catholic.
You see, I agree with this and I think it's a powerful demonstration of the sort of blind pass faith and religion get in our society.

Now, I don't think Chris Stedman is saying we should dispose of such arguments. You can take that last argument and substitute been deluded.

It all comes down to how accurate we wish to be when we throw around terms like crazy or mentally ill and I would be the first to admit that I sling these around like a pro. Basically, it means we should always do our best to think before we speak.

I'll cut to the point. I know people who suffer or have suffered with mental illness. I think it's much more common than people realize and I believe there is still a stigma associated with it. Some of these people do not believe in God or religion.

Furthermore, I myself believed in this religion stuff. Was I mentally ill? I would answer no (well at least not for that reason!). I was deluded, brain-washed and indoctrinated.

Now, some strong religious beliefs might cause enough trauma to result in some mental illness - PTSD for example. However, these are not the result of all religious beliefs. They can flow out of religious beliefs.

Don't get me wrong, please. This doesn't get religion off the hook. I still think it's dreadful and virus-like, impedes progress and, when implemented, can cause great harm. I just find myself agreeing with Chris here. It's not a mental illness (although it can trigger mental illness). And faith in particular, when understood as believing something for which there is no evidence, is delusional and can be dangerous, but it is not an illness.

After I thought about this, I came to this compromise when it comes to what I say or write. I will not use terms like mentally ill or mentally damaged unless I really mean it in the clinical sense of the word.

When it comes to terms like crazy or cray cray or insane or nutty or fruit-loops, I think these have enough grounding in colloquial speech that they can be kept. I am not diagnosing someone with a medical condition. I'll have no problem calling inanimate objects these things but will still think twice before using the terms to describe individuals or a group of people. If at all possible, I'll reserve these terms for the beliefs or ideas these people may have - their delusions.

The same goes for terms like lost your mind.  It's not in the same league as armchair diagnosing someone as mentally ill.

I'm not getting all preachy here. This is just for me. It's a little editorial meta.

What did you think of this article?

9 comments:

  1. I don't really know how I feel about this. Does anyone take mental illness as a part of their identity? Or is it a burden that people try to manage/cure?


    Calling a boring party "gay" is easier to call, because it takes something that is integral to many people's identity and using it as a synonym for "bad." But is it insulting to people with cancer to say that religion is "like a cancer in society"? I don't think so, because people don't generally celebrate their cancer. Rather, they fight it, they try to get rid of it. In the same way that people with mental illness try to fight it, or at the very least try to manage it.

    So I don't necessarily think that we should be frowning on the use of "mental illness" as a description of religion because of the risk of harming people with mental illness. It's not, I think, adding to the stigma to say that mental illnesses are not positive, awesome things.


    But on the other hand, I don't think it's accurate, and I'd like us to strive for accuracy when we make open statements (when speaking privately within a small group, such as with friends, then that group dynamic takes precedence over any "political correctness," obviously - so there's room for a distinction between formal and informal speech). The fact is that there *is* a difference between the guy who thinks that his pancakes are actually the body of Elvis and the guy who thinks that his crackers are actually the body of Jesus, and the difference is that the first guy came of his belief all by himself and maintains it despite everyone around him disagreeing. The second guy learned it from his parents (probably) and is reinforced over and over again by his community. That difference is important.


    That doesn't mean that we can't talk about how religion can nurture or reinforce mental illness, or make it very difficult to diagnose mental illness when symptoms are framed in language familiar to dominant religious beliefs. We can even talk about how religion is *like* a mental illness in that its tenets are generated and maintained independently from rational processes. But I do agree with those who have argued that it simply not accurate to just wave our hands dismissively and say "oh, religion is just shared delusion."

    I also think that it's lazy. It's so easy to just call things stupid, or crazy, or gay. That these expressions have so much grounding in colloquial speech is a very good reason to stop using them. As skeptics, we should be trying to think through our thoughts and the language we use to express them, rather than falling back on the easiest linguistic shortcuts. At the very least, we should do this because it's good practice for thinking through bigger assumptions we may be making.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Attention:

    Do you need an urgent personal/business loan? Here is your life time opportunity you have been waiting for, we the management and staff of the Lady marian loan funds Plc are here to put an end to your financial needs.

    We offer loans at 1% interest rate. For your financial solution, Think no further. contact us today for your financial solution via our company e-mail: Ladymarianloanfunds@aol.com

    Kind Regards.
    Lady Marian loan funds plc.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I can believe is possible that HIV can be cure what a great man he have done it for me also I never believe all this comment and post about him, I was very sick, I am HIV positive over 2 year,just last year I keep reading the testimony post about this man named odudu they said that the man is so powerful he have cured to different diseases, I keep monitor the post of some people about this man and I found out this man is real I contacted him for help because I was having such problem this man reply to my email after some hours, I inform he about my problem that I have this virus for 2 year now this man said that I should not worry and I should not disappoint him, what he about to do for me now is just a gift from his gods and his father’s that I s should regard him if am cured I should write the true about him, I said no problem because I never have the believe that I will be cured someday but thanks god for my life for curing me through this man this man ask for my details which i send for him, and he said that he want to have some consultation on it how to get me cure I wait for his respond this man reply me back after some minute he said that I need to provide so thing need for the curing I try and do so after everything is done I found out I was again my strength back my tissue start developing he ask me to go for hospital test I did and I found out there was no HIV found in my body again what a miracle thanks doctor for help me out from this illness i will continue doing this according to my promise if you need his help just contact him now through his email or phone number oduduspelltemple@hotmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  4. how i got back my lover3 March 2014 12:34

    Hello, I want to inform you all that there is a spell caster that is genuine and real. I never really believed in any of these things but when I was losing Garvin, I needed help and somewhere to turn badly. I found consultant. trust spells and i ordered a LOVE SPELL. within the next 24 hours, my phone rang. Garvin was his old self again and wanted to come back to me! Not only come back, the spell caster opened him up to know how much I loved and needed him. Spell Casting isn't brainwashing, but they opened his eyes to know how much we have to share love together. I recommend anyone who is in my old situation to try it. It will bring you a wonderful surprises as well as your lover back to you. The way things were meant to be." you can contact the spell caster on spellofsolution@gmail.com he's very nice and great Priest oduma is the real deal call him on +2348153363047

    ReplyDelete
  5. Bob is delusional, he suffers from delusions which normally aren't harmful, but some people who have the same delusions have been known to neglect their children. Some have even been convinced they are hearing voices commanding them to harm others.


    Bob deserves our sympathy. But there is no reason to show respect for his delusions. And it doesn't harm anyone to recognize the fact that Bob suffers from these delusions.

    And it is important to distinguish Bob from people who don't suffer from these actual delusions, but instead only hope they could one day have them. People who long and even pray that they too could suffer from this illness.


    Those people deserve contempt.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Dr EKUKU is the best spell caster ever.

    i just have to share this testimony

    Dr Ekuku is the best spell caster ever,I just have to share this good news with you out there. After Philip and I had words this morning,just three days after i contacted Dr Ekuku.Then this evening around 7:30 he sent me an sms to say he wanted to talk. Naturally I played hard to get, then he said he still loved me and that he was sorry.We ironed out a few issues so we are back on speaking terms,Dr Ekuku is to thank for the sudden turn around in Philip after he cast the reunion spell. Thank you so much for putting a smile back on my face again. Even Philip seems happier and admitted that he was miserable since the fall out we had 6 months ago. I will definitely recommend your site to all my friends. I am a believer.if you are facing hard times with you love life or any problem at all reach Dr Ekuku on ekukutempleofsolution@gmail.com.

    Name: SHERYL

    Location:Amsterdam, Holand

    ReplyDelete
  7. Honestly as a person who suffers from severe depression, I dont care if they get called crazy. I am crazy after all, but the difference is that I helped myself while thesists are not trying to help themselves so they are more crazy.

    ReplyDelete
  8. QuietContemplation4 March 2014 11:24

    Very good points. I have been trying to refrain from calling anyone's behavior 'crazy' or from saying 'something is wrong with him/her', because it is stigmatizing to many people. I find most religious beliefs to be nonsensical, but nonsensical does not equate mentally ill. Someone who is mentally ill just can't change their beliefs, and be done with their illness.

    However, I do think a lot of people who are mentally ill do gravitate toward religion in a delusional way, and that is different than just minor magical thinking. Thinking you're Jesus, or that Jesus talks to you, gives you orders, ect... is mental illness, and that person would be just as ill if religion didn't exist as they are with it. Delusional thinking is severe, and pervasive in a person's life, and simply not having a belief in God would not make them suddenly not ill anymore.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I WANT TO THANK GREAT DR UTIMATE 2ND FOR HELPING ME WITH MY LOST HUSBAND DEVIS HOLLYWOOD...

    Dr utimate is like a father to the fatherless.. i never believed these will really make a change in my marriage, and i never have it in my thought that i could ever been with my husband Mr Devis after divorcing and ending our 33years marriage.... My life was upset i never knew where to start from when my husband broke up with me.....My name is Tanisha Davis from Poland but got married and live in Chicago USA, utimatespellhome@gmail.com is the right email address to contact for an urgent help in getting your lover back.... My husband and I have been together for 33years before he divorced me and i was so upset because i thought i have lost my marriage forever... i did all i could to please for my husband to bring me back home but all to be in vain.. i had to traveled away from my state because i was not having anywhere to stay because my home was not conducive for me to stay because my husband want me out of the house, i travel to a friend of mine in California, one night, when i was searching on a good spell caster results that help in bringing back lost lover's and husband's, i found an interesting story that was shared by Santana Valdez From Texas Huston, about a good spell caster called Dr utimate,and how he helped her in getting her husband back home, and i decided to put a try in contacting him... he replied me back.. i thought at first these was just normal and he told me that i was going to get back my husband after a period of 28hours i still doubted him.... But today as i am sharing these good news is for me to express my experience to all the whole universe that these is a good spell caster that helps in bringing back lost lovers and he is (utimatespellhome@gmail.com ) I am happily with my husband and my 3 kids, TARRY, WENDY, JEFF... great utimate i thank you for helping me to get my family back.... his email address is (utimatespellhome@gmail.com) Thanks, From Tanisha Davis

    , utimate is my Grandfather because he was always there for me when i needed him mostly and he is the reason why i am happy today.

    ReplyDelete